The conclusion: we liked HaoZip, 7-Zip, and PeaZip best, in that order.
Since then, some readers have alerted us to two new programs that are worth considering: Bandizip and Bitser, both of which provide a good range of features and functions (see below).
The following table provides a quick feature overview:
Bandizip
Bitser
screenshot
Interface
Nice interface; supports drag and drop; a good-looking; customizable context menu. Very cool ‘preview archive’ option in the context menu.
Nice interface; supports drag and drop; a good-looking context menu (which however is not customizable).
Interesting features
High speed archiving/ multi core compression; unicode filenames; can extract multiple archives into multiple folders; ZIPX format support (packing and upacking); multiple icon packs.
Calculate folder size and delete empty folders via context menu; provides AES-256 encryption; the ability to create or extract multiple archives from the context menu; a checksum calculator.
Packs
ZIP (z01); ZipX (zx01); TAR; TGZ; 7Z (7z.001); and EXE (e01)
This is not meant to be a comparison as such, but an overview. BandiZip is definitely the more serious contender of the two, and I am eager to test it in a head to head comparison with Haozip, which is my favorite compression/archiving program.
Although Dropbox and other cloud services have gotten us used to accessing our files anywhere from the cloud, somehow there is always that important...